Faruk -
I don't propose to debate you here but is highly unlikely that we will ever load
ALL Cisco MIBs and traps. That would make both the snmpmib file and the
trapd.conf file so large that in some environments they may prove to be a
performance problem. The last time I ran the Cisco addtrap script it added
over 400 traps, making Cisco the largest enterprise by far, and it more than
doubled the size of trapd.conf. Not even NetView itself has that many. Perhaps
that has changed.
However, it is not unreasonable to expect that in a future release we will deal
with the most commonly used MIBs and traps, which is why I asked for people to
send me their list of what those are in a previous append.
As am IBMer, I trust you are already well -aware of how to make a request to
development to make your views known.
James Shanks
Tivoli (NetView for UNIX and NT) L3 Support
Faruk Grozdanic <farukg@US.IBM.COM> on 03/03/2000 03:07:03 PM
Please respond to Discussion of IBM NetView and POLYCENTER Manager on NetView
<NV-L@UCSBVM.UCSB.EDU>
To: NV-L@UCSBVM.UCSB.EDU
cc: (bcc: James Shanks/Tivoli Systems)
Subject: Re: How to load and configure cisco mibs and traps?
I have recently loaded most of CISCO MIBS found at
ftp://ftp.cisco.com/pub/mibs. Also I have created addtrap scripts using
mib2trap command to load trap definition. I have not converted all traps
defined in mib definition files ( some gave me compalation errors ), but
does have a vast majority of them. Later today I will tar these up and send
them to the list if no one objects.
Cisco has a script that adds all CISCO traps to NV versions 3 & 4. I ran
this script and it worked rather well ( my platform is AIX 4.3.3 & NV 5.1.1
). It can be foud at ftp://ftp.cisco.com/pub/mibs/contrib. One setback is
that it's rather out of date. We should press Cisco or Tivoli to provide an
updated version of something similar to this ( not an unreasonable request
due to resently formed partnership between IBM & CISCO ).
Future versions of NetView should have at least all the router and switch
Cisco MIBs in /usr/OV/snmp_mibs directory. Also trapd.conf should have trap
definitions for these as well. I do not see why it should not have all
Cisco MIBs loaded and traps defined ( available at time of release or in a
patch ); it is much easier to unload the mib and remove trap definitions
not needed, then to go out and search for them and troubleshoot errors
accompanied by these.
I manage quite a large number of Cisco switches and had to manually add
entries in oid_to_type file ( necessary if you want the symbol in NetView
to reflect that it is actually a switch ) for Cisco 55xx devices. This is
another thing that should be updated in future versions ( do not know if
version 6 already took care of it ). Not to be too picky but a new simbol
for switch should be created by Tivoli, one that would be different form
the Bridge and Hub/Multiport Hub symbols.
Thanks
Faruk Grozdanic
IBM GS SDC - West
(303) 924-3475 T/L 347-3475
|