Re: [nv-l] RFI : meaning of "Interface has no connectivity in unreachable region" ?

["Philippe Menard" <PME@fr.ibm.com>]

I think I'm seeing the light. Do you agree with 
- "Interface has no connectivity in unreachable region"  means  "Interface is unreachable" i.e. "Interface in unknown state"
- "Interface down" (a fact) should have higher priority than "Interface unreachable" (no information)
- the reason the interface is unreachable is that other (router) interfaces are down (high priority !)

Philippe.

- - -

Philippe MÉNARD
Networking Delivery Support Center
Mail : pme@fr.ibm.com
Phone : +33 (0)4 92 11 48 69
Fax : +33 (0)4 93 24 49 07

Paul Stroud <pstroud@bellsouth.net> 08/08/2003 19:37 Please respond to pstroud

To:        Philippe Menard/France/Contr/IBM@IBMFR, nv-l@lists.tivoli.com         cc:        Stephen Hochstetler/Austin/IBM@IBMUS         Subject:        Re: [nv-l] RFI : meaning of "Interface has no connectivity in unreachable region" ?

At that point, the device is not "down", it is acutally unreachable, NetView 
knows this so it changes the status from "down" to "unreachable". For this
to happen a trap must be generated and processed. This will update the
status in the database.

Paul



On Friday 08 August 2003 13:32, Philippe Menard wrote:
> Stephen,
>
> I know the purpose of RFI and I see we share the same definition of an
> unreachable region.
>
> What I can't understand is : once a region is unreachable, what additional
> information is provided
> by the "Interface has no connectivity in unreachable region" event ? Don't
> we already know
> that all the interfaces connected to this region are down ? Am I missing
> something obvious ?
>
> Best regards,
> Philippe.
>
> - - -
>
> Philippe MÉNARD
> Networking Delivery Support Center
> Mail : pme@fr.ibm.com
> Phone : +33 (0)4 92 11 48 69
> Fax : +33 (0)4 93 24 49 07
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Stephen Hochstetler/Austin/IBM@IBMUS
> 08/08/2003 19:05
>
>
>         To:     Philippe Menard/France/Contr/IBM@IBMFR,
> nv-l@lists.tivoli.com cc:
>         Subject:        Re: [nv-l] RFI : meaning of "Interface has no
> connectivity in unreachable region" ?
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> I am going to take a shot at this....and let Paul or someone else let me
> know if this is wrong.    RFI is suppose to reduce the number of
> IBM_NVIDWN_EV being send when a whole subnet is not pingable by NetView.
> How does NetView know this....simply by NetView knowing all the router
> interfaces in a particular subnet.    When NetView sees all the Router
> interfaces down in a single subnet, NetView is smart enough to know it
> will
> not be able to ping any computers in that subnet...so it stops polling the
> computers.   But it still pings the router interfaces waiting for them to
> come back up.
>
> Case 1:  The interface is down.    No known impact to other
> nodes/interfaces is known.   If this is from a router, then NetView must
> be
> able to ping other router interfaces in that subnet yet.
>
> Case 2:  The interface is down.   Since NetView is suppose to stop pinging
> computers in an unreachable region, then this must be coming from the
> router interface that signifies that ALL router interfaces are down in
> that
> subnet (unreachable region).    I would say that this reported "problem"
> should have higher priority than case 1, since a whole region of the
> network is affected.
>
>
>
>
> Stephen Hochstetler              shochste@us.ibm.com
> International Technical Support Organization at IBM
> Office - 512-838-6198 (t/l 678)       FAX - 512-838-6931
> http://www.redbooks.ibm.com
>
> |---------+---------------------------->
> |
> |         |           "Philippe Menard"|
> |         |           <PME@fr.ibm.com> |
> |         |
> |         |           08/08/2003 11:50 |
> |         |           AM               |
> |
> |---------+---------------------------->
> |
> >--------------------------------------------------------------------------
> >------------------------------------|
> >
>   |       To:       nv-l@lists.tivoli.com       |
>   |       cc:                                       |
>   |       Subject:  [nv-l] RFI : meaning of "Interface has no connectivity
>
> in unreachable region" ?              |
>
> >--------------------------------------------------------------------------
> >------------------------------------|
>
> All,
>
> NV 7.1.3, AIX 4.3.3
>
> I have realized that the IBM_NVIDWN_EV event (EID = nv6000, specific =
> 58916867) is now used in (at least) two cases :
> 1- the usual Interface Down event with a description such as "Interface
> Ethernet0 down."
> 2- the RFI event with a description such as "Interface Ethernet0 has no
> connectivity in unreachable region"
>
> Please could someone explain the meaning of the second event.
> Is it OK to consider this event as a plain "Interface Down" event ? (as
> suggested by the reuse of the trap)
>
> Best regards,
> Philippe.
>
> - - -
>
> Philippe MÉNARD
> Networking Delivery Support Center
> Mail : pme@fr.ibm.com
> Phone : +33 (0)4 92 11 48 69
> Fax : +33 (0)4 93 24 49 07
>
>
>
>
> ---------------------------------------------------------------------
> To unsubscribe, e-mail: nv-l-unsubscribe@lists.tivoli.com
> For additional commands, e-mail: nv-l-help@lists.tivoli.com
>
> *NOTE*
> This is not an Offical Tivoli Support forum. If you need immediate
> assistance from Tivoli please call the IBM Tivoli Software Group
> help line at 1-800-TIVOLI8(848-6548)