IBM Director does not use the Trap Service and that is a problem, but we're
considering some workaround options. How can we disable NetView from
trying to get the traps from the Trap Service as well as have NetView not
start up the SNMP Trap Service when it starts up? Basically we don't want
the Trap Service involved and will handle catching the incoming traps and
forwarding them to the interested applications through a different
application.
Thanks
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Johanna Hislop | Software Development | IBM Tivoli Storage Area Network
Manager | 507-253-7647 | jhislop@us.ibm.com
James
Shanks/Raleigh/IB
M@IBMUS To
Sent by: nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com
owner-nv-l@lists. cc
us.ibm.com
Subject
Re: [nv-l] Disabling port 162 use
04/29/2004 05:17
PM
Please respond to
nv-l
IBM Director is supposed to use the Trap Service. It was for them that we
made the switch to the Trap Service ourselves, back when they first came
out.
James Shanks
Level 3 Support for Tivoli NetView for UNIX and Windows
Tivoli Software / IBM Software Group
Johanna Hislop/Rochester/IBM@IBMUS
Sent by: owner-nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com
To
nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com
04/29/2004 06:05 PM cc
Subject
Please respond to Re: [nv-l] Disabling
nv-l port 162 use
Well, the issue with just using NetView's trapforwarding is that we're
dealing with SNMP v2 traps in some situations. The other application is
IBM Director. I follow what you're saying, but am not sure about IBM
Director's capabilities. I'm kind of in the middle of it, as I see NetView
is too. I'll take this info back and see if this helps the people working
on this issue.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Johanna Hislop | Software Development | IBM Tivoli Storage Area Network
Manager | 507-253-7647 | jhislop@us.ibm.com
James
Shanks/Raleigh/IB
M@IBMUS To
Sent by: nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com
owner-nv-l@lists. cc
us.ibm.com
Subject
Re: [nv-l] Disabling port 162 use
04/29/2004 04:06
PM
Please respond to
nv-l
In order to use the Trap Service, you have to be written to use one of the
Microsoft APIs for the Trap Service, such as SnmpMgrGetTrap. That's the
lowest level API. There are more sophisticated ones to get SNMP V2 traps.
If you aren't written to do this, but expect to listen on port 162/udp
directly, then only one application on the box can get traps, and it in
turn must forward to all the other trap receivers, else they get nothing.
I don't understand exactly what "The system being set up wants an
application other than ITSANM/NetView to be picking up the SNMP traps from
port 162." means. I think you are saying that you have some other
application that you want to put on the box and also get traps. Well, it
has to be coded to use the Trap Service for this to be simple. It is
isn't, then you will have trouble making the these apps co-exist.
If the other app can use another port, then trapfrwd in NetView can be
coded to send traps to that port on the same box. If it can't, and it has
to own 162/udp, then the question is, can it forward what it receives to
another port on the same box? If not, then you are out of luck.
Do you follow this? What application are we talking about? Can you ask
its vendor about its capabilities?
James Shanks
Level 3 Support for Tivoli NetView for UNIX and Windows
Tivoli Software / IBM Software Group
Johanna
Hislop/Rochester/IBM@IBMUS
Sent by: To
owner-nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com
cc
nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com,
04/29/2004 02:54 PM owner-nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com
Subject
Re: [nv-l] Disabling port 162
Please respond to use
nv-l
Thanks for the info. I should have known that it was the trap service
using it. The system being set up wants an application other than
ITSANM/NetView to be picking up the SNMP traps from port 162. Should both
applications be able to get the traps from the MS Trap Service without
having to make a choice over which application gets it and then has to
forward it to another application or have that application just go without?
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Johanna Hislop | Software Development | IBM Tivoli Storage Area Network
Manager | 507-253-7647 | jhislop@us.ibm.com
James
Shanks/Raleigh/IB
M@IBMUS To
Sent by: nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com
owner-nv-l@lists. cc
us.ibm.com
Subject
Re: [nv-l] Disabling port 162 use
04/29/2004 12:33
PM
Please respond to
nv-l
Actually, it isn't. Not by default any way. The Microsoft Trap Service is.
And NetView's trapd uses an API to get traps from the Service. Any other
well-behaved MS app can do the same thing. NetView started using the Trap
Service back in Version 6, so that other apps could be installed on the
same Windows box and get traps too. So normally there is no good reason to
alter that.
But if you must, you can make him stop using the MS Trap Service and then
listen on any other port you choose by editing the Registry.
And this isn't recommended though possible.
Is this really what you want to do? Why?
James Shanks
Level 3 Support for Tivoli NetView for UNIX and Windows
Tivoli Software / IBM Software Group
Johanna Hislop/Rochester/IBM@IBMUS
Sent by: owner-nv-l@lists.us.ibm.com
To
nv-l@lists.us.ibm.co
04/29/2004 01:17 PM m
cc
Please respond to Subject
nv-l [nv-l] Disabling
port 162 use
How can I set up NetView 7.3 for Windows to not listen on port 162?
Thanks
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Johanna Hislop | Software Development | IBM Tivoli Storage Area Network
Manager | 507-253-7647 | jhislop@us.ibm.com
|